A Personal View by Remy Majangkim
KOTA KINABALU: Malaysia is built on the principle of constitutional supremacy. While Article 42 of the Federal Constitution grants the Yang di Pertuan Agong the prerogative of mercy, that power is meant to exist within a framework of clear, established laws, rather than in a legislative vacuum.
When we examine the Prison Act 1995 alongside Article 42, a glaring gap appears.
The Prison Act contains no actual legal framework, rules, or safeguards for serving a sentence under house arrest.
Because Parliament had yet to pass a dedicated House Arrest Act, the law was left incomplete. Instead of waiting for elected lawmakers to establish clear, equal rules for everyone, that legislative gap became a convenient justification to stretch existing definitions.
Authorities turned a private residence into a prison under old statutory provisions to enforce a royal decree.
This legal ambiguity becomes even more complex when looking at how the SRC International conditional pardon interacts with the separate 1MDB conviction.
Following the payment of the reduced RM50 million court fine in the SRC case, the conditional pardon unlocked house arrest for the remainder of that sentence until August 23, 2028.
However, in the main 1MDB trial, the High Court ordered the multiple charges to run concurrently with each other for an effective 15 year prison term, while ruling that this 15 year term must run consecutively after the SRC sentence finishes.
Even though the court refused to pause the 1MDB sentence pending appeal, the consecutive structure means the prison clock for 1MDB does not start until the SRC house arrest term expires in August 2028.
For ordinary citizens watching from the outside, seeing a convict sentenced to 15 years without a stay of execution remain at home under a separate pardon creates deep confusion over how sentencing and clemency operate together.
To protect the integrity of our legal system and prevent makeshift workarounds in the future, Malaysia needs four clear reforms:
1. A Dedicated House Arrest Act. Parliament must pass a standalone law with strict eligibility criteria, electronic monitoring standards, and clear enforcement rules. House arrest should be a transparent option governed by equal rules for ordinary prisoners, not a custom privilege for VIPs.
2. Clarifying the Scope of Article 42. Either through a Federal Court ruling or constitutional clarification, we need clear boundaries on whether the prerogative of mercy only allows a sentence to be forgiven, delayed, or reduced, or whether it permits creating new hybrid punishments not found in statute.
3. Updating the Prison Act 1995. Sections 3 and 8 of the Act allow the Home Minister to declare any building a prison, a power meant for temporary lockups or overflow facilities, not private residences. These definitions must be tightened so they cannot be used as backdoor administrative workarounds.
4. Stronger Judicial Oversight. While courts do not question why mercy is granted, they must retain the power to review how a pardon is implemented to ensure ministerial and prison actions strictly obey Acts of Parliament.
True constitutional monarchy requires a delicate balance between royal prerogative, parliamentary lawmaking, and the rule of law. When legal loopholes and overlapping sentences are used to create tailored arrangements, it leaves the public questioning whether the Constitution is truly supreme, or simply open to interpretation.
